Lesson 6 of 6

Agent or simple workflow? Choosing well

Many jobs sold as "agent" work are better done by a simple, predictable workflow. Here's how to tell which one a job needs.

3 min readBy Michael Alos

After five lessons on agents, here's the most useful advice in this course: most small business jobs don't need an agent. They need a well-built workflow, sometimes with an AI step in the middle.

What's the difference?

  • A workflow follows the same steps every time, in the same order. "When a form is submitted, add the person to the CRM, send a welcome email, and notify the office." It's predictable and easy to check.
  • An agent decides its own steps based on the situation. It's flexible, which makes it powerful for messy jobs and harder to predict.

A workflow with an AI step sits in between. The steps are fixed, but AI handles one part that needs language skills. "When an inquiry arrives, AI drafts a reply, then it goes to a person for approval."

When a workflow is the better choice

Choose a workflow when:

  • The steps are the same every time
  • You need predictable results you can easily check
  • Mistakes are costly, so you want to know exactly what will happen
  • You want it cheap to run and easy for your team to understand and change

Most admin, data entry, follow-up and reporting jobs fit here.

When an agent earns its place

Consider an agent when:

  • The steps vary a lot from one case to the next
  • The job needs judgment about which information to find and use
  • A person currently handles it by investigating, not by following a checklist
  • You can put good guardrails around it

Examples: researching a prospect before a sales call, working through a mixed inbox, or answering detailed questions that need several sources.

Five questions before you build or buy

  1. Are the steps the same every time? If yes, start with a workflow.
  2. What happens if it gets one wrong? The higher the cost, the more you want predictability and approval.
  3. Is the information it needs written down? If not, fix that first.
  4. Who checks the output, and when?
  5. How will you know it's working? Time saved, faster replies, fewer errors. Pick one measure before you start.

Try this (5 minutes)

Take the multi-step task you've been working on through this course. Answer the five questions above for it.

Does it need an agent, a workflow with an AI step, or a plain workflow? Write your answer and one sentence explaining why.

Common mistakes

  • Building an agent because it sounds more advanced, when a workflow would be cheaper and more reliable.
  • Assuming "AI-powered" means a product is better for your job.
  • Starting without a way to measure whether it's working.

Check yourself

What's the difference between a workflow and an agent?

A workflow follows the same steps every time. An agent decides its own steps based on the situation.

When is a workflow usually the better choice?

When the steps are the same every time, results need to be predictable, mistakes are costly, and you want it cheap and easy to manage.

What should you decide before building either one?

How you'll measure whether it's working, such as time saved or faster replies.

Want help putting this to work?

Book a free intro call. We’ll talk about your business, find the repetitive work, and work out where AI can actually help. No pitch, no obligation.

Book a free intro call →